Vinyl Reviews Reviewers Choose Their Best of 2018

Year-end “best of” lists are as traditional and fun as spinning vinyl itself. And since no single human can possibly hear every new album released in a calendar year, consider our reviewers’ choices the equivalent of strongly endorsed favorites. Our five regular contributors honored three albums for each of three separate categories: Music, Packaging, and Sound. The only rules? Music entries needed to be new albums released in 2018, while Packaging and Sound candidates had to have been vinyl released in 2018—reissues included. (An asterisk designates a reissue.)

Suffice it to say the albums—many of which have been reviewed on VinylReviews.com, some of which have not, and some which have reviews forthcoming—do not disappoint. In short, if you haven’t yet heard or held these LPs, get to it!

 

Bob Gendron, Music Editor


Music

Best: Janelle Monae Dirty Computer (Atlantic)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Runner-Up: Brandi Carlile By the Way, I Forgive You (Elektra)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Honorable Mention: Idles Joy as an Act of Resistance (PTKF)

Buy at Amazon

 

Packaging

Best: Guns N’ Roses Appetite for Destruction: Locked N’ Loaded Edition (Universal)

Buy at Music Direct

 

Runner-Up: Metallica …And Justice for All: Deluxe Edition(Blackened)

Buy at Amazon

 

Honorable Mention: Prince Piano & a Microphone 1983: Deluxe Edition (Warner Bros.)

Buy at Amazon

 

Sound

Best: Gillian Welch Soul Journey (Acony)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Runner-Up: U2 Achtung Baby (Island)

Buy at Amazon

 

Honorable Mention: Guns N’ Roses Appetite for Destruction(Universal)

Buy at Amazon

 

Todd Martens, Fiancé of Regrettes Singer Lydia Night


Music

Best: Janelle Monae Dirty Computer (Atlantic)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Runner-Up: Mitsky Be the Cowboy (Dead Oceans)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Honorable Mention: Superchunk What a Time to Be Alive (Merge)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Packaging

Best: Kamasi Washington Heaven & Earth (Young Turks)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Runner-Up: Eric Dolphy Musical Prophet (Resonance)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Honorable Mention: Julia Holter Aviary (Domino)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Sound

Best: Kamasi Washington Heaven & Earth (Young Turks)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Runner-Up: The Beatles The Beatles (White Album) (Capitol)

Read Review Buy at Amazon

 

Honorable Mention: Arctic Monkeys Tranquility Base Hotel + Casino(Domino)

Read Review Buy at Amazon